New Zealand has just passed a major anti-online piracy law, drawing a mixture of outrage among netizens and praise from online copyright proponents and the European Union.
The Copyright (Infringing File Sharing) Amendment Bill allows for three strikes against people who illegally download copyrighted material: internet service providers (ISPs) will give three written warnings before penalties including internet disconnection for up to six months and fines of up to $NZ15,000 can be incurred.
The EU Commission said the law was in line with international best practice.
New Zealand is targeting the EU as a key trading partner, and Privacy Commissioner Marie Shroff said the new law was “a key step towards obtaining a formal legal finding from the European Commission that New Zealand is a safe destination for European companies to send personal data for processing.”
“The finding will be significant for cross-border trade and will open doors for New Zealand business,” she added.
However, New Zealanders came out against the law for the way in which it was passed (under urgency without the usual level of debate), the lack of clarity in the legislation, and for what many see as harsh punitive measures that could see innocent people punished. Creative Freedom Foundation director Bronwyn Holloway-Smith said that disconnecting internet access was “unnecessary and it’s disproportionate”.
ISPs say they will help police the new law but are concerned about who will pay for the cost of providing users’ information to copyright holders.
The latest law is a watered-down version of one withdrawn in March 2009 that would have made ISPs responsible for dealing with people accused of breaches, even if the assertion was unproven.









